Proposition 5: Statewide Officers

Proposition 5: Changes Recall Election Process for Statewide Officers. Legislative Constitutional Amendment.


Additional Titles

Recall Reform, Eliminate State Officer Recall Successor Elections Amendment

Summary

The California Senate introduced Senate Constitutional Amendment 1 (SCA)  in January of 2023. As the Legislature cannot amend the California Constitution by passing legislation, the amendment must be approved by California voters. The Senate passed the bill in February of 2024 and the Assembly passed an amended version in August of 2024. The Senate agreed with the changes to the bill sending the proposed constitutional amendment to voters on the November 2026 ballot as Proposition 5. 

Proposition 5 would amend California’s constitution by changing the recall process. Specifically, it would eliminate the part of the ballot that asks voters to choose a replacement for the official being recalled. If an official is recalled, the office would instead be treated as vacant and filled under the existing state constitution and state law. Legislative vacancies would generally be filled through a separate special election, while most other statewide offices would be filled by appointment by the Governor. If the Governor is recalled, the Lieutenant Governor would take over, either temporarily until the next statewide election or for the remainder of the term, depending on when the recall occurs.

Fiscal Impact

(Summary of Legislative Analyst's Estimate of Net State and Local Government Fiscal Impact)

The financial impact would depend on how often recalls occur and which offices are involved. Costs could increase by millions of dollars when a recall creates a vacancy that requires a separate special election, particularly for legislative offices. At the same time, eliminating replacement candidates from recall ballots could save millions in some elections by reducing ballot and election-material costs. Overall, Proposition 5 could result in either costs or savings of potentially millions of dollars per recall election, although the effect would be very small compared with the state’s overall budget.

What your vote means

YES: A “yes” vote supports changing California’s recall process so voters would decide only whether to remove an official, with the vacancy filled later under state law. A recalled official could run again, and the Lieutenant Governor would generally replace a recalled Governor. 

NO: A “no” vote supports keeping the current recall process, in which voters decide whether to remove an official and simultaneously vote on who should replace that official if the recall succeeds.

Official Voter Information

Non-partisan Voter Information

Public Opinion Polls

Pro/Con Statements

ProCon

Supporters argue that the current recall system can allow a replacement candidate to win with only a small share of the vote, particularly in low-turnout elections. They claim that Proposition 5 would make recalls more democratic and less confusing for voters while reducing opportunities to use recalls for political manipulation.

 Opponents argue that voters should have the right to choose a Governor’s replacement at the time when they approve a recall. They say automatically allowing the Lieutenant Governor to take over could leave voters with a leader who shares the recalled Governor’s political views, limiting voter choice and weakening the purpose of the recall process. 

SupportersOpponents
  • Californians for a Prosperous Golden State, Fix the Recall Yes on 5
  • California Common Cause
  • California Democratic Party
  • League of Women Voters
  • Indivisible CA: StateStrong

The IGS Library has not located an official campaign website in opposition of the ballot measure.

See the Proposition Ballot Endorsement Table for additional supporters and opponents.

Certified Results

YesNo
Total Votes:Total Votes:
Percent of Vote:Percent of Vote:
Source: California Secretary of State. Election Results, Statement of Vote.